Metavid

Video archive of the US Congress

House Proceeding 03-18-09 on Mar 18th, 2009 :: 1:35:20 to 1:55:20
Total video length: 4 hours 20 minutes Stream Tools: Stream Overview | Edit Time

Note: MetaVid video transcripts may contain inaccuracies, help us build a more perfect archive

Download OptionsEmbed Video

Views:1,200 Duration: 0:20:00 Discussion

Previous speech: Next speech:

John Yarmuth

1:31:45 to 1:35:20( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: John Yarmuth

John Yarmuth

1:35:18 to 1:35:20( Edit History Discussion )

John Yarmuth: than willing to try to fix. because we owe thato the

Ron Klein

1:35:21 to 1:35:41( Edit History Discussion )

Ron Klein: american taxpayer. and with that, i'd yield back to my colleague from florida. mr. klein: i thank the gentleman. i think you've summed it up exactly right. and that is, the american people want answers. they want to make sure this doesn't happen again. it's unacceptable for there to be cycles where this happens and you clean up and it happens again.

Ron Klein

1:35:25 to 1:37:35( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Ron Klein

Ron Klein

1:35:42 to 1:36:03( Edit History Discussion )

Ron Klein: i mean, this is, you know, a very significant time for everyone. and the challenge is great. and so we are going to have to focus on it and if i can, i'll just spend one last minute refereing the fact that we're now moving into the conversation about our budget for next year. but talking about the kinds of things the american people are looking for, it's transparency and openness when we have a budget.

Ron Klein

1:36:04 to 1:36:24( Edit History Discussion )

Ron Klein: and the last mber of years of which this group here has only been here two years but the wars, wh appreciate the work that our military did and all the rest of that, but $100 billion some for the last number of year, not even on the books of the balance sheet of the federal government, every year it's a supplemental budget. supplemental budget is supposed

Ron Klein

1:36:25 to 1:36:46( Edit History Discussion )

Ron Klein: to be when you have an emergency. god forbid you have a katrina or something like that that you didn't plan for. the war was ere, it should have been planned for and accounted for. when you talk about a balanced budget and here today, we're fi deficit people. we're deaf he sit hawks. we believe in -- we're deficit hawks. we believe in it. the republicans didn't do it,

Ron Klein

1:36:47 to 1:37:07( Edit History Discussion )

Ron Klein: democrats didn't do it in the past but all of us together have got to get it right now and the goin we inherited an unfortunate budget and it's gog to take time to get through this. mr. spratt who works with us, president obama's got a lot of ideas, we're going to put them through the mix here and i think we something, but most importantly, it's an honest, open conversation. the american people are smart

Ron Klein

1:37:08 to 1:37:29( Edit History Discussion )

Ron Klein: people. they understand the process of building a budget. they do it for themselves every day. and i look forward to the opportunity of working with republicans, or maybe differences of opinions in priorities. i happen to believe that education and health care and energy, making this country energy independent is a very forward-thinking way of addressing the next generation

Ron Klein

1:37:30 to 1:37:35( Edit History Discussion )

Ron Klein: of where we need to be but we'll get through that process but the point of it is an honest, open process where the american people can understand

John Yarmuth

1:37:36 to 1:37:51( Edit History Discussion )

John Yarmuth: all the debts, all the possibilities, all the opportunities to buila stronger country. i'll turn it back over to the gentleman from kentucky.?b

John Yarmuth

1:37:40 to 1:37:50( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: John Yarmuth

Stephen Cohen

1:37:52 to 1:38:12( Edit History Discussion )

Stephen Cohen: >> we only have a couple of minutes left. i think this conversation has been a good one and i'm glad that they joined us for it. i yield briefly to my colleague from memphis. >> i just join with my colleagues in saying how good it is to have the opportunity to clean up this mess.

Stephen Cohen

1:37:55 to 1:38:20( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Stephen Cohen

Stephen Cohen

1:38:13 to 1:38:20( Edit History Discussion )

Stephen Cohen: president bush is to be commended for saying he hope this is president succeeds he puts his country before his party.

Bruce Braley

1:38:21 to 1:38:42( Edit History Discussion )

Bruce Braley: i hope his colleagues and members of his party will listen to him, not his vice president before it should have been broken. with that i yield to the gentleman from iowa. >> the concluding remarks i want to offer to the american people, a.i.g. is now the symbol of

Bruce Braley

1:38:25 to 1:39:35( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Bruce Braley

Bruce Braley

1:38:43 to 1:39:05( Edit History Discussion )

Bruce Braley: arrogance inspires greed. the other thing is american people expect us to provide justice with superior firepower. we've got a lot of intellectual firepower on both sides of the aisle, we've got a lot of creative people with experience, my colleague's reference about cleaning up, i did a lot of time

Bruce Braley

1:39:06 to 1:39:27( Edit History Discussion )

Bruce Braley: doing janitorial work putting myself through college and law school. i'm excited to be here at this point in t we need bright, creative people with critical thinking skills and together we'll solve this problem. >> i thank my colleagues. i look forward to our conversations next week, next wednesday, and as we go through the year it's a great honor for

Bruce Braley

1:39:28 to 1:39:39( Edit History Discussion )

Bruce Braley: me to serve with so many thoughtful, dedicated representatives and with that, mr. speaker, i yield back

1:39:40 to 1:40:01( Edit History Discussion )

balance of my time. the speaker pro tempore: under the speaker's announced policy of january 6, 2009, the chair recognizes the gentleman from pennsylvania -- missouri, excuse me. i couldn't tell which microphone you were going to.

1:40:02 to 1:40:22( Edit History Discussion )

for 60 minutes as the designee of the minority leader. >> thank you, mr. speaker. we have a number of interesting topics we're talking about tonight. even a little bit of a challenge question for people feeling imaginative and innovative, it's a strategic question about some votes coming up tomorrow on the floor.

1:40:23 to 1:40:44( Edit History Discussion )

it should be interesting, but joining us first off this evening is my good friend, congressman pitts, who hails from pennsylvania and has come up with quite a barrage of different colorful charts here. i don't know if it looks like somebody's -- some part of a

Joseph R. Pitts

1:40:45 to 1:41:06( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: critical measurement of somebody's life expectancy, so i'm going to yield time to congressman pitts who has been a congressman for a long time, highly respect ared, from pennsylvania. so gentleman, i yield you time and i'd like you to tell us a little bit about what you've graphed here, because they're quite interesting. mr. pitts: thank you, mr.

Joseph R. Pitts

1:41:05 to 1:42:20( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Joseph R. Pitts

Joseph R. Pitts

1:41:07 to 1:41:28( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: for yielding. there is an old saying that a picture is worth a thousand words. i think sometimes, mr. speaker, pictures help explain some otherwise complicated situations. so i've assembled some data about the economy and vernment spending and put them on charts

Joseph R. Pitts

1:41:29 to 1:41:49( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: to help explain some of the facts. and i think the overall emphasis is that there are economic consequences to what we do and what we say here in congress. there are economic consequences to our taxation and spending, our budget policies. and i'd just like

Joseph R. Pitts

1:41:50 to 1:42:11( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: explain some of the colors on the chart and go through them. on the chart you see red and blue and lines, the colors here indicate which party is in control of congress. so where you have red, you have

Joseph R. Pitts

1:42:12 to 1:42:22( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: -- that is the control of congress is in both house and senate is republican. you have here and here in these years republican control.

Joseph R. Pitts

1:42:23 to 1:42:45( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: where you have blue that is both chambers being controlled by the democrats. where you have the slanted marks, you have a divided congress. so here, the house is democrat and the senate is republican. in the smaller lines, you have the house republican and the senate democrat. and we have a range of years

W. Todd Akin

1:42:46 to 1:43:07( Edit History Discussion )

W. Todd Akin: here from 1977 to 2009. and at the bottom, you can see president carter, here, from 1977 to 1981. then reagan. and these white dash marks show president. >> just reclaiming my time a second, i think what you're

W. Todd Akin

1:43:08 to 1:43:25( Edit History Discussion )

W. Todd Akin: saying, you're really putting a lot of information on one picture, aren't you? the white dash lines are transitions in terms of presidency, the blue collar represents the democrat color, the red is the republican coo thrork hash marks is a mixed bag, republicans in one body,

Joseph R. Pitts

1:43:26 to 1:43:36( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: democrats in the other. you've got a whole timeline close to 20 years or so.

Joseph R. Pitts

1:43:26 to 1:45:23( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Joseph R. Pitts


Joseph R. Pitts

1:43:37 to 1:43:59( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: go ahead, proceed. mr. pitts: if you look at how the market reacts, the dow jones in yellow, it's going along nicely until it hits the red section then it moves sharply up. you have a divided legislature and to be fair, you had the dot com collapse and 9/11 as well as

Joseph R. Pitts

1:44:00 to 1:44:15( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: the switch of jeffords to make the divided congress. then you hit the red, it goes sharply up, as long as president bush is there to veto the tax changes the democrats in this mr. akin: it sounds like to me

Joseph R. Pitts

1:44:16 to 1:44:36( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: this is stock market advice you're offering today. what you're saying is, if you see the republicans in charge of the house and senate, go buy some stocks. is that what you're trying to tell us? mr. pitts: i'm saying markets react to rhetoric. on again, off again tax cuts, rhetoric about tax increases affect the market dramatically

Joseph R. Pitts

1:44:37 to 1:44:41( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: in a negative way. you can see this drop here.

Joseph R. Pitts

1:44:42 to 1:45:02( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: this second chart is unemployment, which is sort of a mirror image in the strong periods and in the weak periods with the recessions. the second charts are deficit and job growth.

Joseph R. Pitts

1:45:03 to 1:45:23( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: so if you look at these yellow bars, these are budget deficits. notice under president obama, this deficit here. $1.752 billion. this bar. that is more than all of the eight of the previous administration under bush combines.

W. Todd Akin

1:45:24 to 1:45:45( Edit History Discussion )

W. Todd Akin: mr. akin: reclaiming my time. that little yellow line is so close to the edge that my first time i saw that, i just about missed what you're saying. this is absolutely, this looks like some sort of science fiction thing. let's go through it. if you add up the yellow bars between those two sets of dotted

W. Todd Akin

1:45:24 to 1:49:30( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: W. Todd Akin


W. Todd Akin

1:45:46 to 1:46:06( Edit History Discussion )

W. Todd Akin: lines which represents the eight years of the bush years. mr. pitts: that's correct, from here to here. mr. akin: and president bush was being beat up because the republican were spending too much money. was that true? mr. pitts: i remember when they were attacking him for $250 billion deficits.

W. Todd Akin

1:46:07 to 1:46:28( Edit History Discussion )

W. Todd Akin: mr. akin: i voted against a lot of that spend bug reclaiming and taking a look at the chart, if you add up all those bush deficits together, how does that compare to that huge jump you see this year? mr. pitts: the deficit of $1.752 trillion is more than all of the

W. Todd Akin

1:46:29 to 1:46:50( Edit History Discussion )

W. Todd Akin: eight years, the previous eight years combined. mr. akin: more than all eight years of bush? you add all eigh you're saying in this year, is this 2009? you're saying in 2009, we have more deficit we've wracked than all eight years of the bush? mr. pitts: that's correct. i could have really scared you

W. Todd Akin

1:46:51 to 1:47:11( Edit History Discussion )

W. Todd Akin: and showed you proposed deficits in the future. mr. akin: my heart might not handle that. i notice we've been joined here by, i believe, congressman rooney from florida, bringing a the charts. i'd yield some time, or yield to congressman rooney.

Thomas Rooney

1:47:12 to 1:47:32( Edit History Discussion )

Thomas Rooney: mr. rooney: thank you, sir. i appreciate the chart first and foremost because what i wanted to jump in and tell you, as we've been joined by some children in the chamber and you know, this past weekend, i had the opportunity to go camping with my kids in central florida and it all sort of dawned one

Thomas Rooney

1:47:12 to 1:49:04( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Thomas Rooney


Thomas Rooney

1:47:33 to 1:47:55( Edit History Discussion )

Thomas Rooney: and hit me at once as we are now referred to as the party of no. when you see a chart like this and you see what these children are about to face and what my three young sons who are 7, 5, and 2 are about to face, why we are the party of no. we heard recently from the other side as they were here, how

Thomas Rooney

1:47:56 to 1:48:19( Edit History Discussion )

Thomas Rooney: outraged they were at a.i.g., how outraged they are at some of the things going on. this is why we vote no. this is exactly the reason why we have to stand by our children and not saddle them and put on their backs what you are displaying on that chart there, sir, so at we can keep our financial house in order and

Thomas Rooney

1:48:20 to 1:48:41( Edit History Discussion )

Thomas Rooney: allow -- translate to them a america that's better than we inherited. we are on the cusp, as one of my friends in florida likes to say, of being the first generation of americans that leaves to their children an america that's worse off than what we received. that's all on us. so we can sit here all day and talk about how outraged we are

Thomas Rooney

1:48:42 to 1:49:04( Edit History Discussion )

Thomas Rooney: at a.i.g. and what's happened with these bonuses being paid out, that was agreed to and voted on by this congress even though a lot of us on the republican side voted no, to be called the party of no and to see this and now to hear the democrats say they're outraged by what's happened --

W. Todd Akin

1:49:05 to 1:49:25( Edit History Discussion )

W. Todd Akin: mr. akin: reclaiming for a minute, do you know what just occurred today made it obvious why we need to be saying no to that big porkulous bill. it had, as we knew it would be, all these little things hidden in it. we'll be talking about some of the things hidden in it that were announced on abc news

W. Todd Akin

1:49:26 to 1:49:30( Edit History Discussion )

W. Todd Akin: recently. we've also been joined by a doctor, we have an increasing

Bill Cassidy

1:49:31 to 1:49:54( Edit History Discussion )

Bill Cassidy: number of doctors in the congress and the goo cassidy from louisiana. i yield time to dr. cassidy. mr. cassidy: thank you. as you're talking about this, two thin you mention how taxes have the ability to create uncertainty. now, if we just take this not from the

Bill Cassidy

1:49:35 to 1:50:50( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Bill Cassidy

Bill Cassidy

1:49:55 to 1:50:16( Edit History Discussion )

Bill Cassidy: it down to a family, in louisiana they are taxing, this new budget is going to tax oil and gas exploration. 90% of ail and gas is done by not exxonmobil but small wildcatters if you will. these folks eloy about 320,000 people in my state in petrochemical. these are great jobs.

Bill Cassidy

1:50:17 to 1:50:38( Edit History Discussion )

Bill Cassidy: they give benefit, they allow people to pay their mortgage. they're not service level in that sense. but they are jobs of the type that you can raise a family. so earlier, we heard our democratic colleagues peeking -- speaking about our need for energy independence. i'm struck. i'm new here, so i don't quite derstand it, we want energy independence.

Bill Cassidy

1:50:39 to 1:50:50( Edit History Discussion )

Bill Cassidy: we want to create good jobs for working folk with good benefits. help the uninsured. but at the same time, we're penalizing a domestic energ

Joseph R. Pitts

1:50:51 to 1:51:12( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: industry which cannot move because it's domestic which is helping our energy independence and creating jobs. mr. pitts: would theentleman yield? i serve on the energy and commerce committee, we are having hearings on the new proposals, cap and trade they call it, of the obama

Joseph R. Pitts

1:50:51 to 1:51:45( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Joseph R. Pitts


Joseph R. Pitts

1:51:13 to 1:51:34( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: administration. in a time of economic uncertainty, families and businesses and small businesses have to conserve. they have to be more efficient. they have to save. they have to be a lot more frugal. this is not the time to massively expand the federal government.

Joseph R. Pitts

1:51:35 to 1:51:45( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: we should be doing what we're supposed to do in a more frugal way a more efficient way. and yet the new administration is proposing vast new proposals

W. Todd Akin

1:51:46 to 1:52:07( Edit History Discussion )

W. Todd Akin: in the area of government-owned health care in the area of cap and trade, aax on all use in the united states. mr. akin: reclaiming time here, i recall standing not very far from where i'm standing here on the floor of the house and hearing thpresident make a promise and i felt good when he made the promise. he said i'm not going to tax

W. Todd Akin

1:51:50 to 1:52:40( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: W. Todd Akin


W. Todd Akin

1:52:08 to 1:52:28( Edit History Discussion )

W. Todd Akin: anybody who is making less than $250,000, and i sort of slumped back in my chair and said, at least he missed me. now we're talking about cap and trade and what he's going to do is increase the energy costs on every household across our country. doesn't make any difference how much money you're making if you're using electricity or burning fuel, you'll get zapped

W. Todd Akin

1:52:29 to 1:52:40( Edit History Discussion )

W. Todd Akin: and the average is $3,000 per household. when you see that big yellow line, that isn't just a big line on a graph. we're talking about families in america and all of our

Joseph R. Pitts

1:52:41 to 1:53:04( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: districts getting saddled. and this is just one proposal. this is ju, quote, cap and trade. >> will the gentleman permit me to speak here? the cap and trade proposal really has eight taxes on energy and the president's proposing to raise $646 billion with this new cap and trade

Joseph R. Pitts

1:52:45 to 1:54:05( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Joseph R. Pitts

Joseph R. Pitts

1:53:05 to 1:53:25( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: so this big line here, the deficit here, which makes the -- all the other deficits look small in reflecting these massive new government programs. in not we, but the congress passed, the creation of 31 new

Joseph R. Pitts

1:53:26 to 1:53:47( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: federal programs and an expansion of 73 existing programs. massive government spending. that's what's reflected in this. could i just point one other thing snou mr. akin: certainly. pitts pitts there's a good lessen -- mr. pitts: there's a good lesson in here. you see these four years when the republicans controlled the house and senate, speaker gingrich was here, i served on

Joseph R. Pitts

1:53:48 to 1:54:06( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: the budget committee with. and because -- on the budget committee. and cause the republicans in congress worked with president clinton, clinton deserves some credit, we deserve some credit, we balanced the budget four years in a row, consecutive, and paid down on the public debt, four years in a row.

Joseph R. Pitts

1:54:07 to 1:54:29( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: real bipartisanship works. wanting us to come in at the last minute and vote for something without having any bipartisanship and creating -- in creating the bill, in crafting the bill at first, that will not work. real bipartisanship is good for the country. not calling us in, trying to buy out three votes at the end

Thomas Rooney

1:54:30 to 1:54:52( Edit History Discussion )

Thomas Rooney: of the i'll yield back. mr. akin: the gentleman from florida, congressman rooney. mr. rooney: i believe when we recently, what the american public, at least my constituents were expecting, was the bipartisanship that you're talking about.

Thomas Rooney

1:54:35 to 1:56:20( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Thomas Rooney


Thomas Rooney

1:54:53 to 1:55:14( Edit History Discussion )

Thomas Rooney: and i got to tell you, it's the biggest disappointment from taking the oath of office and starting as a congressman, that t i don't know if that's how it's worked. obviously it has worked in the past. but that's not what we're getting now in this congress and it's an extremely disappointing, eye-opening phenomenon that unfortunately

Thomas Rooney

1:55:15 to 1:55:35( Edit History Discussion )

Thomas Rooney: we have to endure. i just want to expand a little bit on what the gentleman was talking about with regard to the $250,000. on top of what you're talking about with cap and trade or cap and tax as some people like to call it, with the people who are going to have to pay the $3,000 per household to afford

Personal tools

MetaVid is a non-profit project of UC Santa Cruz and the Sunlight Foundation. Learn more About MetaVid

The C-SPAN logo and other servicemarks that may be found in video content are the property of their respective trademark holders. None of these trademark holders are affiliated with Metavid